The Comfort Apothecary
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact

Which Element Are You? Take the Four Elements Personality Quiz

7/28/2026

12 Comments

 

In this post and this one, I talked about the difficulties I had with the original quiz I had made. Well, my second attempt is finally complete! Read on to see what I learned and how you can take the quiz, yourself.
​ 
Picture

Revising the Four Elements Quiz


Whew! I worked hours and hours and hours on revising this quiz.

I had an understanding of the elements that kept bumping up against the way the quiz was written.

Every time Earth came up, I'd say, "No...this is Water." Then I'd second-guess myself because ChatGPT kept insisting it belonged to Earth. 

So I found myself trusting the description in front of me more than the inner knowing I'd had for years.

Eventually I went digging through old notes I'd written two decades ago, and there it was. The Water I'd remembered all along.

Picture

My Four Elements Quiz Results


So I took the quiz again and there was a surprise!

Do you remember that one reason I wanted to rework the quiz was that I had a primary element (Water, at the time) but felt called to the result for Spirit? Well, we created the quiz and I decided to exclude Spirit and focus instead on the western understanding of the 4 elements, not the five.

And I had suspected that I would eventually find out that I was Air, because it was close to what we had written for Spirit. But that's not what happened.

My primary element is still - WATER! And it's my secondary that is Air 

​Which element feels like home? Which one takes over when you’re afraid? Which one have you mistaken for a need because it is your oldest coping strategy? Which one comforts you? Which one challenges you? And which one feels like the woman you are becoming? - ChatGPT
Picture

​The Water & Air Pairing


Water and Air feel like they are who I am becoming.

The way I was living was strengthening my Air so much that I assumed it was my primary element.
​
But now, I need to think more in terms of how my Air can support my Water. And how Water expresses itself through my Air. 
​
Picture

​​Air is wonderful at finding the path. Left to itself, though, it would walk me right past home in pursuit of one more answer. Or finishing one more thing.

Water is the one that takes my hand and says, "Let's stop here for a while," and brings me tea, and starts the movie.
​

The Takeaway


Sometimes we don't lose ourselves because we've changed. We lose ourselves because the way we've been living no longer reflects who we're becoming.

And it's my hope that when you take the quiz, you will not only discover who you are, but what you need and how to give that to yourself.
​​
See you next time!

​Love, Jeanine
​
12 Comments
Martha link
7/28/2026 01:39:58 am

Well that was an interesting quiz. Some questions didn't have any answer that fit me so I took the next best one like in #16. I got 6 in both A and B, 5 in D and 3 in A. So looks like I'm tied with Earth and Water and Fire a close third.

Reply
Jeanine Byers link
7/28/2026 02:53:58 am

Interesting! You know, I can see those qualities in you, Martha. Were you able to see them in yourself when you read the descriptions?

Reply
Tamara link
7/28/2026 07:13:59 am

Took the quiz during my lunch hour. Looks like I'm overwhelmingly water, which is no surprise, since I am a Pisces. A hint of fire and sprinkles of earth and air (3 points each).

Reply
Jeanine Byers link
7/28/2026 09:26:09 pm

Oh, right! I guess it isn't a surprise then. But you know, I have a water trine, but Air really gave me a run for my money.

Reply
Dani Pescuma link
7/28/2026 08:02:10 am

Ahhhh... the quiz!!! Finally! 🤩 I LOVE this, Jeanine (and again, your illustrations are LUSH!). So, these were my results: 5 As, 5 Bs, 6 Cs and 4 Ds. So, I'm a "combination" of Air with Earth and Water. 🤗

This was so cool to do. Thank you. :)

Reply
Jeanine Byers link
7/28/2026 09:28:10 pm

Wow, a trifecta! Basically, it sounds like you are very balanced, which is wonderful. I wonder if your scores are a sign of growth. I suspect so.

Reply
Patricia Thomson
7/28/2026 11:37:16 am

First of all I absolutely love your illustrations! Do you do them yourself? I love your site too. I took the quiz and I am Earth with a side of Water. So interesting! Thank you for sharing!

Reply
Jeanine Byers link
7/28/2026 09:30:31 pm

Thank you so much!! I love the illustrations, but I am only the director, LOL. ChatGPT makes the pictures. It's been fun experimenting with them. So Earth and Water! That's great. They can be a great support for each other.

Reply
Barbara link
7/28/2026 12:44:16 pm

That was a fun quiz. I am overwhelmingly water.

Reply
Jeanine Byers link
7/28/2026 09:32:55 pm

Wow! You and I would get along really well. I am far more Water than Air, but I can still see - now that I'm paying attention - what an influence Air is, too.

Reply
Kebba Buckley Button link
7/28/2026 08:12:34 pm

Jeanine, this looked really interesting. I am more familiar with the 5 Chinese traditional elements-- Earth, Air, Fire, Water, Wood. I tried taking the quiz, but there were questions where none of the answers were remotely right for me, or 3 of 4 were. :-) I gather, in this system, I am more Earth than other elements. Thanks for the exercise!

Reply
Jeanine Byers link
7/28/2026 09:35:19 pm

Oh, that's interesting! Are you also Earth in the 5-element system? I trained for fashion feng shui in a system that had Wood but also had Metal, and ultimately, it didn't stick.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Hi, I'm Jeanine

    ​I've got a cup of tea nearby, a journal within reach, and one more cozy idea than I have time to create. Here I write about comfort, future self living, spiritual growth, rituals, and all the little things that help us remember who we are.​

    Picture

    Archives

    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024

    Categories

    All
    Comforting Rituals
    Emotional Self Care
    Emotional Self-care
    Guided Journal
    Guided Meditation
    Hero's Journey
    Holiday Tips
    Inner Goddess
    Journal Healing
    Mindful Healer
    Sacred Rituals
    Sacred Self
    Self Care
    Self-care
    Self Love
    Self-love
    Shadow Self
    Slow Living

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact